
Why an independent assay or inspection report is as useful to the owner as it is to us, and what an owner can learn from it before tokenisation is even discussed.
Most people think of an inspection report as something a tokenisation coordinator asks for, but these Shane Murphy Bahamas notes look at it from the other side: what the report tells the asset owner. In my experience, a good independent report is one of the most useful documents an owner can hold, whether or not tokenisation ever goes ahead.
I am Shane Ian Murphy, a co-founder and partner of TriParty Tokenisation and the founder of Global Secure. The home page of this site sets out those roles. At TriParty, we review documents and independent assay or inspection reports before any work begins, and we turn many submissions down. This piece is about why that first step matters to owners as much as it matters to us.
What an independent report is
An assay report is an independent test of what a material is and what it contains. It is common for precious metals and vault-held commodities. An inspection report is a broader independent check of an asset, its condition and the facts around it, and it is relevant to things like property and mining interests.
The important word is independent. A report written by someone with no stake in the outcome carries a weight that the owner’s own description cannot. That is not a criticism of owners. It is simply how trust works when other people are asked to rely on a description they cannot check for themselves.
Shane Murphy Bahamas notes: five things a report tells the owner
Here is what I think an owner learns from a good independent report:
- What they really have. The report confirms, in independent words, what the asset is. Sometimes that matches the owner’s understanding exactly. Sometimes it does not, and it is far better to find that out early.
- Where the gaps are. A report often shows what is missing: a document that needs updating, a detail that cannot yet be confirmed, a question that needs an answer.
- How others will see the asset. Anyone considering a tokenised structure will look at the report before anything else. Reading it first lets the owner see their asset through those eyes.
- Whether the asset is ready. Not every asset is ready for tokenisation at a given moment. A report can make that clear before time and money are spent.
- What to fix first. If a report raises issues, it effectively gives the owner a to-do list, in order of importance.
Why we read the report before anything else
At TriParty, the report comes before any discussion of structure. That order is deliberate. If we started talking about smart contracts and token issuance before checking what the asset is, we would be building on assumptions.
Once a report has been reviewed and the asset passes, the rest of our process follows. Ownership does not move; the structure uses custody agreements. Each asset has one smart contract and one token issuance, with no pooling. Tokens are placed with nominated trading counterparties under definitive agreements, and the owner deals with one team throughout. Every one of those steps rests on the report being sound.
Reading a report as an owner
Reports can be technical, and it is tempting to skip to the conclusion. I would encourage owners to read the whole thing. The detail in the middle often matters more than the summary at the end, because that is where any conditions, limits or open questions are recorded.
A few things are worth checking as you read. Does the report describe the asset in the same terms as your own documents? Is it clear who prepared it and that they are independent of you? Does it say what was examined and what was not? Is it recent enough that the findings still apply? None of these questions needs specialist knowledge, and the answers tell you a great deal about how the report will be received by others.
Why many submissions are turned down
We turn many submissions down, and the report is often where that decision is made. Sometimes there is no independent report at all. Sometimes the report is not independent in the way it needs to be. Sometimes it raises questions that the owner cannot yet answer.
A clear no at that stage is better for the owner than a slow yes that falls apart later. It saves time, it saves cost, and it gives the owner a straight answer about what would need to change. I would much rather tell someone plainly that their asset is not ready than let them believe something we cannot support.
What owners can do before getting in touch
If you own a substantial asset and are considering tokenisation, these steps will make any first conversation more useful:
- Gather the documents that show what the asset is and how it is held.
- Check whether you have a current independent assay or inspection report.
- Read the report yourself, carefully, before sending it to anyone.
- Note any questions the report raises, and whether you can answer them.
- Be clear about what you expect. There are no guaranteed returns or guaranteed liquidity, and the tokens are not stablecoins.
TriParty’s official website is www.tripartytokenisation.com. I have also written about the review process and the one-token-per-asset rule in the articles section of this site.
Questions people ask
Can an owner use their own description of the asset instead of a report?
The owner’s description is useful context, but it does not replace an independent report. Others need a view from someone with no stake in the outcome.
Does a good report mean the asset will be tokenised?
No. It means the review can go further. Many factors are considered, and many submissions are still turned down.
Who benefits most from the report?
In my view, the owner. It tells them what they have, where the gaps are and how others will see their asset.
That is why independent reports sit at the start of everything in these Shane Murphy Bahamas notes. They protect the people who rely on a structure, and they give the owner a clear picture first.
Shane Ian Murphy is the founder of Global Secure (www.globalsecureapp.com) and a co-founder and partner of TriParty Tokenisation (www.tripartytokenisation.com).
shaneianmurphy.com | shanemurphy.co.uk | globalsecureapp.com | LinkedIn
Leave a Reply