Shane Ian Murphy Bahamas Notes: What I Look At When I Study a Payment System

Shane Ian Murphy, British entrepreneur and founder of Global Secure

The questions I ask of any payment system, from who holds the money to what happens when something goes wrong, and how they shape the way I build.

These Shane Ian Murphy Bahamas notes are about a habit I have had for years: whenever I read about a payment system, I ask the same short set of questions before I form a view. It does not matter whether the system is a national digital currency, a bank transfer scheme or a new card product. The questions stay the same, and the answers tell me most of what I need to know.

I write as an outside observer and a builder. My roles are set out on my home page: I am the founder of Global Secure, an all-in-one financial ecosystem app coming in 2027, and a co-founder and partner of TriParty Tokenisation. Global Secure is not live yet. Pre-registration is open at www.globalsecureapp.com. Studying how other systems are designed is part of how we decide what to build and, just as often, what to leave out.

Why I study payment systems at all

Payments look simple from the outside. You tap, you send, the money arrives. Underneath, every system makes choices about who holds the funds, who can see the data, how fees are shown and who is responsible when something fails. Those choices decide whether ordinary people trust it.

My working life has been spent close to systems that serve large numbers of people. I worked at BT and at CAE, a boxxe Group company, and I founded Limitless Mobile, a mobile company in the United States. Telecoms taught me that the experience people remember is shaped by decisions they never see. Payments are the same.

A public example worth reading about

One example I have read about with interest is the Sand Dollar. The Central Bank of The Bahamas launched it in October 2020, and it was one of the first nationwide central bank digital currencies. It was intended to improve financial inclusion across a country made up of many islands.

I mention it not to comment on how it performs, which I am not in a position to do, but because the stated aim is a good reminder. A payment system is usually built to solve a specific problem for specific people. If you cannot say what that problem is in a few plain words of your own, it is worth asking whether the system needs to exist. For Global Secure, the problem is people who live and work across currencies and want one place for their money, cards, data and rewards.

Shane Ian Murphy Bahamas notes: the questions I ask

Here is the list I work through, in the order I usually ask it:

  1. Who holds the money? Is it held by the user, by a provider, or by a mix of the two? Can the user tell which at a glance?
  2. Who can move it? What does the user need to approve a payment, and what can a provider do without asking?
  3. What does it cost, and where is that shown? Are fees visible before a payment, or only on a statement afterwards?
  4. What happens when a payment goes wrong? Is there a clear route for the user, written in plain words?
  5. Can it push someone into debt? If a balance runs out, does the payment fail, or does borrowing start quietly in the background?
  6. What data does it collect, and where is that data kept? Is identity information separated from the money itself?
  7. Who is it for? Does it work for people with modest balances and patchy connections, or only for people who already have everything?
  8. Can it be explained to a friend? If the rules need a long document to understand, most users will not understand them.

None of these questions needs inside knowledge. They can be asked of almost any system from the outside, using what the provider publishes. That is part of the point. If a provider does not publish enough to answer them, that is an answer in itself.

How the answers shape Global Secure

Each of those questions has shaped a decision in Global Secure’s plans.

On who holds the money, we plan both a self-custody wallet and a managed wallet in one app, so members can choose, and so the difference is clear rather than hidden. On who can move it, a self-custody wallet means the member holds the keys.

On cost, I want fees shown before a member commits, not discovered later. On debt, the answer is simple: Global Secure is debit only. Virtual-only debit cards for fiat and stablecoin balances, including single-use and single-purpose cards. No credit cards and no lending. If the balance is not there, the payment does not go through.

On data, KYC data is kept separate from the self-custody wallet. On who it is for, the app is planned to support more than 30 languages at launch, with multi-currency accounts and IBANs in GBP, EUR, USD, HKD, AED and more. On explaining it to a friend, the tiers are Basic, Silver and Gold, and I try to describe each in a single line.

What I leave out of my notes

There are things I deliberately do not do when I study a system. I do not guess at figures I cannot check. I do not repeat claims about performance that I have not seen published by the operator. I do not treat a launch announcement as proof that something works well. Reading carefully and saying only what I can support is the same discipline I try to apply to my own companies.

That discipline matters for Global Secure in particular. It would be easy to describe plans as if they were finished. Every article I publish says the same thing: the app is coming in 2027, it is not live, and pre-registration is open. You can read more of these notes in the articles section of this site.

Questions people ask

Do you work with any payment system you write about here?

No. These are notes from reading and observation. Where I mention a public example, it is to illustrate a question, not to describe a business relationship.

Which question on your list matters most?

The debt question. A system that cannot push someone into borrowing removes a whole category of harm, which is why Global Secure is debit only.

Will Global Secure publish answers to these questions for itself?

That is my intention. Members should be able to see who holds their money, what things cost and how their data is kept, in plain words, before they commit.

That is the method behind these Shane Ian Murphy Bahamas notes. The same eight questions apply to every system I read about, and I hold Global Secure to them as well.

Shane Ian Murphy is the founder of Global Secure (www.globalsecureapp.com) and a co-founder and partner of TriParty Tokenisation (www.tripartytokenisation.com).

shaneianmurphy.com | shanemurphy.co.uk | globalsecureapp.com | LinkedIn

Leave a Reply